I don't want to bash these ideas or anything, I think they'd be wonderful if they did work, but they won't. We might be able to show which people have power and all, but it doesn't mean the player mindset is going to follow. The only way to do it is increase the severity of punishments, as otherwise, the idea is not getting across to people. Yes, it's all well and good having a system some players might look at, but when a player might not look at that and oppose the place anyway, it's more a mindset that needs to be put to the playerbase and even though it seem's rather forced, you won't get these dreams without pushing an opinion onto people that they may just completely ignore or get gnarked with and either way, it'll only be the people who look at the forums getting this mindset as many people might not even see these.
The problem is the opinion, punishment severity is what is needed; however there will never be a perfect mindset unless you push an opinion onto the playerbase for realism, which people don't like.