It's whatever the writer decided can or can't exist in their fantasy world.
They (legion, naelwyn, sally) cannot please everyone and it can't be very nice for them to have to keep battling questions regarding why decisions have been made and why this or that isn't allowed.
First of all I want to compliment you on this wonderful comparison of playing on this server and writing a story. It speaks to the imagination and makes the point clearer than normal words could have done.
Second, I think the lore team is doing a good job. They
must have full control over what changes on the server. Of course! and they
will get battling questions regarding their decisions, because their decisions involve other people (the average player) as well. But that is the good thing. They do their thing and change the server, and we can compliment, negotiate, argue with them. Even if it would just be hypothetical, I still think these battling questions serve a purpose.
There are people on this server who like these decisions. There are people that don't.
They (the lore team) cannot please everyone.
I want to affirm that not pleasing everyone is what leads to the best results. It is a common
law in architecture that when you try to please everyone, nobody will like/use your creation.
But if you try and follow a vision, and so please a certain group, you can almost be sure your creation will be liked and used. This is why it doesn't matter that some do not like it, it is still better than trying to please everyone.
This thread has taken an amazing course and I will keep my eyes on further developments.
this community.